The Perfect Grind: Why Your Pressure Gauge is Too High (Over-Extracted/Choking)

As a home barista, seeing your Breville pressure too high on the gauge—spiking well beyond the ideal espresso zone—signals over-extraction or “choking,” where the puck resists water flow excessively, leading to bitter, astringent shots.

This comprehensive guide breaks down the symptoms, root causes like overly fine grinds or heavy tamping, step-by-step fixes, advanced OPV tweaks, and long-term prevention to dial in perfect pulls every time.

What High Pressure Looks Like on the Gauge

On Breville machines like the Barista Express, the pressure gauge is your window into brew dynamics. The espresso zone is marked in gray, centering around 9 bars—the gold standard for balanced extraction.

Normal vs High Pressure

Reading	Gauge Position	What It Means
Normal	Middle zone (9-10 bar)	Proper extraction
High	Right zone (11+ bar)	Too much resistance
Maxed	Far right/red	Choking - puck is blocked

Visual Signs of High Pressure

• First drips appear after 10+ seconds (struggling through pre-infusion)
• Slow “mouse tail” drip or near-stall
• Gauge climbs rapidly and stays pinned high
• Shot takes 35+ seconds for minimal output
• Little to no crema despite long extraction

Pro Tip: Hold the shot button continuously to prevent pump cycling spikes that can exaggerate gauge readings.

Signs of Over-Extraction and Choking

High pressure leads to over-extraction, which has distinct characteristics:

Taste Profile

• Bitter - Harsh, unpleasant bitterness (not pleasant dark chocolate)
• Astringent - Dry, puckering sensation on tongue
• Burnt/ashy - Charred, smoky notes
• Hollow - Initial intensity but empty finish
• No sweetness - All the unpleasant compounds, none of the good ones

Visual Indicators

Sign	What You See
Flow rate	Dripping, not flowing
Color	Dark, almost black
Crema	Very dark or absent
Time	35+ seconds for small yield
Puck after	Dry, muddy, or “puck soup”

The Choking Point

When pressure is too high, the machine “chokes”—the pump struggles against a puck that’s essentially impermeable. You’ll hear the pump straining, see little to no output, and the gauge stays maxed.

Common Causes of High Pressure

Let’s address why your gauge is reading too high:

1. Grind Size Too Fine

The most common cause. When grounds are too fine, they create excessive resistance.

Problem	Breville Dial Position	Solution
Way too fine	1-3	Move to 5-6
Too fine	4-5	Move to 6-7
Just a bit fine	6	Move to 7

Adjustment tip: Make changes in 1-click increments while grinding. Give each adjustment 2-3 shots to evaluate.

2. Dose Too High

Too much coffee in the basket creates a taller, denser puck with more resistance.

Standard doses:

• Single basket: 7-9g
• Double basket: 16-18g

If you’re using 19-20g+, try reducing to 17-18g and see if pressure normalizes.

3. Tamping Too Hard

Over-compacting the puck increases resistance significantly.

Solution:

• Apply firm but not forceful pressure (30 lbs target)
• Focus on level more than pressure
• Don’t press with all your strength
• Let the grind do the work of creating resistance

4. Poor Puck Prep / Channeling

Uneven distribution causes water to find paths of least resistance, then suddenly break through, creating pressure spikes followed by fast flow.

Solution:

• Use WDT (Weiss Distribution Technique) with thin needles
• Level grounds before tamping
• Don’t tap the portafilter after tamping

5. Very Fresh Beans (Under 3 Days)

Ultra-fresh beans are still degassing heavily, creating additional resistance from CO2.

Solution:

• Let beans rest 5-7 days post-roast for best results
• Alternatively, grind slightly coarser for fresh beans

Step-by-Step Troubleshooting

Follow this systematic approach:

Step 1: Coarsen Your Grind

This is the first and most effective fix:

1. Move your grind dial 1-2 clicks coarser (higher number)
2. Only adjust while grinder is running
3. Purge 2-3g of grounds to clear old settings
4. Pull a test shot
5. Evaluate: Still too slow? Go 1 click coarser. Better? Fine-tune.

Step 2: Reduce Your Dose

If coarser grind alone doesn’t help:

1. Weigh your current dose
2. Reduce by 1-2 grams
3. For double basket: aim for 17g instead of 19g
4. Test and evaluate

Step 3: Lighten Your Tamp

1. Apply firm but gentle pressure
2. Focus on keeping tamper level
3. Polish with slight twist
4. Don’t “pile-drive” the coffee

Step 4: Improve Distribution

Before tamping:

1. Use a WDT tool to stir and level grounds
2. Tap basket gently on counter to settle
3. Use a distribution tool if available
4. Ensure no clumps or gaps

Step 5: Run Diagnostic Tests

Blind basket test:

1. Insert rubber cleaning disc
2. Lock portafilter
3. Run shot button
4. Gauge should hit maximum (this is normal with no flow)

If gauge doesn’t max with blank disc: Machine issue

If normal with blank but high with coffee: Puck prep issue

Advanced: OPV Adjustment

The Over-Pressure Valve (OPV) regulates maximum brew pressure. Breville machines ship set to approximately 12-15 bar—higher than the ideal 9 bar for quality espresso.

Should You Adjust Your OPV?

Consider it if:

• You’ve optimized grind, dose, and technique
• Gauge consistently reads high with good shots
• You want more control over extraction

Don’t adjust if:

• You’re new to espresso (master basics first)
• Your machine is under warranty (may void it)
• You’re not comfortable opening the machine

OPV Adjustment Overview

Warning: This requires opening your machine and working with internal components. Research thoroughly before attempting.

1. Unplug and let machine cool completely
2. Remove outer casing (screws on bottom/back)
3. Locate OPV (near pump, has adjustable spring)
4. Turn adjustment screw to reduce pressure
5. Reassemble and test with blind basket
6. Target: 9-10 bar reading with blind basket

Recommended resources: Watch multiple YouTube tutorials specific to your model before attempting.

Prevention Tips

Keep your pressure in the optimal zone:

Dial-In Process

1. Start coarse, go finer: Begin at setting 8-9, work finer until you hit 25-30 second extraction
2. One variable at a time: Only change grind OR dose, not both simultaneously
3. Document everything: Track settings for each coffee
4. Accept dialing-in shots: First 2-3 shots of a new bag are experiments

Consistent Technique

• Weigh dose every time (18g ± 0.5g)
• Same distribution method each shot
• Same tamp pressure and technique
• Extract immediately after locking portafilter

Maintenance

• Weekly: Backflush with cleaning tablets
• Monthly: Descale (more often in hard water areas)
• Quarterly: Check gaskets and seals

Bean Management

• Rest beans 5-14 days post-roast for optimal extraction
• Store in airtight container away from light
• Adjust grind coarser for very fresh beans
• Adjust grind finer as beans age

FAQs

My gauge maxes out with the pressurized basket—is my machine broken?

No. Pressurized (double-wall) baskets simulate resistance differently. Low/variable readings are normal. Focus testing with non-pressurized (single-wall) baskets for accurate diagnosis.

My shot flows fast but gauge shows high pressure—what’s happening?

This often means the OPV is dumping excess pressure at 12-15 bar while water still flows through channeled areas of the puck. Coarsen grind and improve distribution.

Is it safe to ignore high pressure if the shot tastes okay?

Not recommended. Consistent high pressure stresses your machine and typically indicates extraction imbalance. What tastes “okay” now could be much better with proper pressure.

What’s the best grind setting for Breville Barista Express?

Start around setting 5-7 for most medium roasts. Dial based on 25-30 second extraction time. Each coffee is different—there’s no universal “perfect” setting.

The pressure drops mid-shot—is that related to high pressure?

Pressure dropping mid-shot usually indicates channeling: water finds a weak spot and breaks through. This is a distribution/puck prep issue, not directly a high pressure problem.

Key Takeaways

• High pressure (>10 bar) = over-extraction from fine grind, high dose, or hard tamp
• Fix priority: Coarsen grind (1 notch) → Reduce dose (2g) → Lighter tamp → Check distribution → OPV adjustment (last resort)
• Target: 9 bars pressure, 25-30 second extraction, 1:2 ratio (18g in → 36g out)
• Prevention: Consistent technique + regular maintenance beats modifications
• Test systematically: Blank basket test validates machine; puck analysis reveals prep issues

Master these fundamentals, and your Breville will deliver café-quality espresso consistently. Remember: adjustments should be small and methodical. The perfect pressure is just a few clicks away.

---

Related Guides:

• Fix Low Pressure (Under-Extraction)
• Fix Espresso Channeling
• Descaling Guide